If there is one themed Survivor season fans have asked for more than any other, it is a season filled with players who were voted out first in the game. It certainly is an intriguing marketing hook, but for years, Jeff Probst’s response whenever the subject was brought up was that there weren’t enough dynamic players to make it work. Well, at least not enough dynamic players without the name Francesca Hogi, who was voted out first on the Redemption Island season, came back again for Caramoan… and was promptly voted out first again. (For the record, Francesca was one of my favorite pre-game Survivor interviews before her first outing.)

But with 49 seasons worth of options now (well, a few less if you throw out returning player seasons since those folks not named Francesca already also made it past the first boot), could a season filled with first eliminated players finally be castable? (Get ready for your close up, Zane Knight!)

Orrrrrr… would a season filled with people who made it all the way to final Tribal Council and lost be more intriguing? There’s obviously an impressive stable of final Tribal Council losers to choose from. Which would you as a fan rather see: a season of all first ones out or all final Tribal Council losers? We have a poll at the bottom of this article for you to officially weigh in. But you are not the only ones we are asking. We posed that same question to the cast of Survivor 50.

Granted, some of them are final Tribal Council losers so they are clearly a little biased, as they may be angling for another trip to the island, but this is also a group that are not only players, but fans. See who picked which and why in the video below, and then cast your own vote for which season you would like to see.